The Nine Wrong Answers

ninewronganswersCarr’s work typically falls into three categories – impossible crimes investigated by Fell, impossible crimes investigated by Merrivale, and some form of historical novel offering some level of impossible crime.  There are a handful of exceptions – The Emperor’s Snuff Box and Poison in Jest being prime examples.  Even in these cases, your going to get something somewhat expected – a baffling crime followed by an investigation to find the murderer.

The Nine Wrong Answers stands apart in that it isn’t a whodunnit  Despite the plot taking place over the span of many days, the story doesn’t really involve any central murder or investigation.  There is no impossible crime, and in a way, there almost isn’t really an outright mystery.  Instead, we’re treated to a chess game between the author and the reader.  At nine points throughout the novel, Carr sheds the convention of story telling and provides footnotes that speak directly to the reader.  Each aside serves as a guide, assuring you that if you were to jump to a predictable conclusion, you would be wrong (hence the book’s name).  Although true to his word, Carr uses these comments to ensare the reader, creating a form of mystery simply by ruling out the probable.

I typically don’t go too deep into specifying the details of the plot in my reviews – laying out the characters, giving their backgrounds, etc.  I prefer to focus on the core hook that would help someone determine if they’d like to read the story.  If this were a typical Carr book, I’d feed you a summary like “a man is shot dead in a locked room surrounded by witnesses but none heard a sound.”  What’s tricky in this case is that The Nine Wrong Answers provides no definitive crime like that.  It is all pure story, forcing me to get into the details.

My take on it is simply this – Bill Dawson, down on his luck in America, is convinced to travel to England to impersonate Larry Hurst in exchange for a handsome payment.  Larry stands to inherit a sizable fortune from his uncle Gaylord, who he hasn’t seen since he was a boy.  The uncle, who was a cruel prankster when Larry was young, has one stipulation – Bill (pretending to be Larry), must visit weekly for 6 months.  During that time, Bill is openly informed, Gaylord will attempt to murder him.

Weeeell……that is quite the plot, isn’t it?  Yeah, it’s far fetched, and the hook requires a bit more explanation than typical Carr.  This isn’t an impossible crime story, it’s a bit more of a thriller.  Tension is created by the main character being immersed in a situation where he clearly doesn’t have control and there is a definite sense of jeopardy.

ninewronganswers2The Nine Wrong Answers is ultimately all about the title – the nine instances where Carr speaks directly to the reader.  Although his comments can appear to provide clarity, they actually add to the puzzle by ruling out obvious conclusions.  Through these nine footnotes, Carr constructs a mystery that goes beyond the simple confines of the plot presented directly by the narrative.  The comments force the reader to focus on details that may not have jumped out otherwise.  Surely if Carr points out something in one of the nine footnotes, it must have some relevance, but how?

In between those footnotes there is plenty going on – murders, murder attempts, poisonings, spying, chases, and action.  One combat scene is reminiscent of the battle between Chevoit and Vulcan during Fire, Burn.  In fact, that’s possibly the closest parallel that I can draw to anything else in Carr’s portfolio.

It all comes together beautifully in the end – having been faced with the nine wrong answers, we finally get the nine correct answers in a triumphant lecture that rivals the best of Fell and Merrivale.  This is the part of the book that really sticks with me – the sense of “wow, I had no clue all that was going on”, combined with “ok, that was fairly clued but there is no way I could have ever caught that detail.

The Nine Wrong Answers stands alone in Carr’s work; a weird yet satisfying anomaly.  I was hoping that The Reader is Warned would contain similar direct challenges to the reader, but the effect wasn’t even close.  In several other previous books, Carr breaks the fourth wall, but in a much more limited sense.  I wonder if he had toyed with the idea of writing something like The Nine Wrong Answers and then decided to go full out later in his career.

It’s worth noting that the book was published in the 1950’s, following the two decades where Carr is commonly regarded to have produced his best work.  Despite this, the story is a typical fixture on top 10 Carr lists.  Although Carr went on to produce other well regarded stories (such as Fire, Burn and Captain Cut Throat), this is probably the final “classic” by the author (the prior being He Who Whispers from 1946).

Is it Top 10 Carr for me?  It is so far, although the jury’s still out – I have quite a few well regarded books to go and it faces some stiff competition.  If you haven’t gotten to it yet, know that this is Must Read Carr.

24 thoughts on “The Nine Wrong Answers”

  1. This is #3 on my top five Carr list that I published perhaps a year ago (only Carr, not Dickson titles). I really enjoy the breaking of the fourth wall and the fact that I was totally fooled the first time through.


    1. Hmm, if I focus only on Carr (not Dickson), I’m thinking this is somewhere around my 6th favorite, falling behind The Problem with the Green Capsule, The Emperor’s Snuff Box, He Who Whispers, Till Death Do Us Part, and The Burning Court. I hope to get to some top 5/10 lists soon!


  2. I definitely like the way Carr manipulates us with the footnotes, but I was ultimately disappointed in this book. it certainly isn’t dull, but I was expecting much more of a traditional mystery while this ends up being more like the adventure story, “The Most Dangerous Game.” Maybe if I’d read your review first and/or been prepared for that, I would have had more fun. One of the frustrating things for me with some Carrs is how small the cast is, which seriously limits how things can turn out. This is an example of that issue; The Reader Is Warned is another (which might account for my figuring out whodunit there!)


    1. The Reader is Warned has the tiniest cast and I still didn’t spot the culprit!

      I can definitely understand how one could be disappointed by the lack of mystery in The Nine Wrong Answers if you were expecting a traditional Carr book (although, hey, by the end you realize there really was a mystery!). Admittedly, I probably had the same expectations as you, but it was my second Carr book, and so I don’t think my expectations were quite as baked.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Golden Age of Detective Fiction

Detective Fiction of the 1920's & 1930's

Solving the Mystery of Murder

Investigating how classic crime writers plot their mysteries.

A Crime is Afoot

A Random Walk Through Classic Crime Fiction

Long Live The Queens!

About Ellery Queen and other GAD authors

James Scott Byrnside

Author of impossible-crime murder mysteries

Countdown John's Christie Journal

A review of Agatha Christie's crime novels and short stories from beginning to end

Dead Yesterday

Classic Mysteries and Domestic Suspense


The annex to John Grant's *A Comprehensive Encyclopedia of Film Noir*

Justice for the Corpse

Reviews of classic fair-play mystery fiction - spoiler-free unless otherwise noted

Composed Almost Entirely of Books

Books read, books written, books I just spotted and covet like an ox

Mysteries Ahoy!

Detecting Great Crime Fiction

Only Detect

Book Reviews, Mostly

%d bloggers like this: