The Gentleman From Paris – John Dickson Carr (1950)


I wouldn’t normally write about a single short story.  At least, I think I wouldn’t.  As much as I love a short mystery, I’ve mostly avoided the form since I started reading through John Dickson Carr’s library.  I know that a few of his shorts share elements with a novel or two, and I’d rather ruin the abbreviated form if it comes to that.  Of course, that shouldn’t keep me from digging into other author’s short stories, but somehow I’ve formed a bit of a habit.

Well, here I am, talking about a short story… by John Dickson Carr no less.  I’ve been making my way slowly through The Quintessence of Queen #2 (#1 is reviewed here), and figured I might as well read the one Carr story contained within.  Suffice to say, it was good enough that I’m actually writing more than a blurb about it.

That’s because it’s kind of interesting to understand where The Gentleman From Paris fits into Carr’s catalogue.  Published in 1950, this was Carr’s second historical work in the run that lasted through the end of his career (yes, you have The Murder of Sir Edmund Godfrey and Devil Kinsmere in 1934/36 respectively, but I don’t think anyone includes those when referring to Carr’s core historical work).  His first historical, The Bride of Newgate, had been published earlier the same year and wove together a swashbuckling adventure with his trademark impossible crime form.  The action/romp element would go on to be perfected in later historicals ranging from Captain Cut-Throat (1955) through The Demoniacs (1962).  The impossible crime element, however, all but evaporated from his historicals up until The Witch of the Low Tide (1961).

That may be why The Gentleman From Paris caught my interest.  This is very much a puzzle. We can debate the extent to which the problem is actually an impossibility, but seeing a historical short of this nature come out right at this point in Carr’s career jumped out at me.  The author has pretty much packed his bags on Gideon Fell – the detective won’t appear again until The Dead Man’s Knock in 1958.  His other core detective, Henry Merrivale, is being wrapped up as we speak with a dreadful showing in Night At the Mocking Widow (also 1950) through The Cavalier’s Cup (1953).  The historicals are pretty much the only spark at this point in his career, other than The Nine Wrong Answers (1952) and (I’ll get hate mail for this) Patrick Butler for the Defense (1956).

The Gentleman From Paris finds the titular character, Armand de Lafayette, stepping off a boat from Liverpool onto the docks of New York City in 1849.  He’s on a mission to find Madame Thevenet, an aged french transplant near her deathbed, in hopes of convincing her to repair her relationship with her poverty stricken estranged daughter in Paris.  Lafayette arrives a few hours too late.  A stroke has left Madame Thevenet paralyzed, unable to speak, and slipping towards death.

The timing is critical.  Madame Thevenet’s will leaves all her possessions to an unscrupulous woman referred to as Jezebel.  The night before her stroke, Madame Thevenet had a change of heart and crafted a new will leaving everything to her daughter in Paris.  The problem is, the new will can’t be found.

We kind of have the impossibility of a missing object on our hands.  We know that Madame Thevenet never left her room during the night (her lawyer was posted outside the door), but an exhaustive search of the room turns up no new will.  Carr also graces us with a form of bizarre dying message.  Although Madame Thevenet is paralyzed, she repeatedly keeps signaling with her eyes towards a pink stuffed rabbit and a barometer.

It’s a fun puzzle that I think will have the gears turning in any reader’s mind.  It’s not just the puzzle though that makes this story so remarkable.  There’s a whole ordeal at a bar when Lafayette first arrives in town that’s a miniaturized version of the best of Carr’s historical elements.  The way that he creates a sense of time and place is one of the aspects of the story that stands out most vividly after reading it.

The solution to the puzzle isn’t one for the ages, but I think everyone reading this will find a delightful little surprise in the end.  This is no The House in Goblin Woods masterpiece of short form, but it really highlighted what these brief stories should inspire to be.  And after reading enough throw away short stories, this was a breath of fresh air.

The version of The Gentleman From Paris that I read was included in The Quintessence of Queen #2 – an anthology of short stories.  It’s notable in that it includes a two page essay following the story that points out a number of subtle clues that should have directed the reader to the final twist.  There is no statement as to who wrote the essay (I assume one of the Queen cousins or Anthony Boucher), but it refers to John Dickson Carr in the third person.

I bring up this short essay not only because it’s filled with interesting bits, but also because it is not featured in my Bantam edition of The Third Bullet – the Carr short story collection that is probably the most widely available way to get The Gentleman From Paris.  Douglas Greene’s biography of Carr contains a note that a version of the story published in Random House’s 1970 Anthony Boucher memorial anthology Crimes and Misfortunes contains a preface written by Carr.  I suspect this is different from the essay given that the frank discussion of the solution wouldn’t make sense as a preface.

11 thoughts on “The Gentleman From Paris – John Dickson Carr (1950)”

    1. Thanks for reminding me of that, I can’t believe I forgot to mention it! I read a review of it on another site and it sounded like the story had been significantly altered from Carr’s original. It was the dramatic difference that left me reluctant to bother tracking down the film – more time to read!

      Liked by 2 people

      1. Well there haven’t been all that many Carr adaptations so I like to whichever ones I can locate – I still need to catch up with the French take on The Burning Court.

        Liked by 1 person

  1. Yeah, I enjoyed the knowing nature of this one (only clear once you get to the end, obviously) and commend Carr for doing something so coy and fun at this stage of his career. One feels that the historical possibilities have rejuvenated him and that he was having a bit of fun…and why not? It’s a lovely little short, one of his better short stories, though for obvious reasons I think its reputation suffers when placed against, say, the March collection just because this one is doing something so very different.


    1. It struck me that my view on the story could be influenced by how I read it as part of an anthology of a wide range of authors. It stood out easily as a gem, but I wonder if that would have been the case if I was burning through a set of six Carr stories in a row. It’s food for thought as I go forward. Is an author’s short story collection best enjoyed as a body of work, or are the individual stories best enjoyed singularly for what they are? I have to think the later.


      1. Unhelpfully, I think it varies from author to author. Stanley Ellin, for instance, wrote in such a staggering range of styles for his short fiction that you can read ten in a row and each one feels fresh and new (it helps that they’re near-universally superb, of course). But after ten Hercule Poirot stories I’d be struggling to care any more. About anything.

        The manner in which they were produced doubtless plays a part — when Leo Bruce is writing one a week for the Evening Standard, that’s obviously a body of work, but is one is written in 1941 and another in 1948…it’s probably a very different author who wrote the second one.


      2. And yet those Poirot stories are a ”body of work” as you put it, seeing as they were all written for Strand in the same year…

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Solving the Mystery of Murder

Investigating how classic crime writers plot their mysteries.

A Crime is Afoot

A Random Walk Through Classic Crime Fiction

Long Live The Queens!

About Ellery Queen and other GAD authors

James Scott Byrnside

Author of impossible-crime murder mysteries

Countdown John's Christie Journal

A review of Agatha Christie's crime novels and short stories from beginning to end

Dead Yesterday

Classic Mysteries and Domestic Suspense


The annex to John Grant's *A Comprehensive Encyclopedia of Film Noir*

Justice for the Corpse

Reviews of classic fair-play mystery fiction - spoiler-free unless otherwise noted

Composed Almost Entirely of Books

Books read, books written, books I just spotted and covet like an ox

Mysteries Ahoy!

Detecting Great Crime Fiction

Only Detect

Book Reviews, Mostly

%d bloggers like this: