The Red Widow Murders

redwidowI’m surprised that I don’t read more about this book.  It doesn’t show up on many Top Carr lists and I haven’t seen it reviewed on many of my favorite sites.  It seems to occupy a strange limbo alongside The Ten Teacups, The Unicorn Murders, The Reader is Warned, and The Mad Hatter mystery – I find very little mention of these books, and yet they seem to be held in fairly high regard.

My verdict?  This could have easily been Carr’s masterpiece.  Could have…  The atmosphere is gripping – possibly his best.  The puzzle is mind bending – possibly his best.  The pace is riveting – again, possibly his best.  Similar to The Judas Window, each successive chapter seems to include its own shattering revelations.  There is even a long fascinating passage set in the time of the French Revolution, dripping with Carr’s usual historical details.

Continue reading “The Red Widow Murders”

She Died a Lady

Juliet died a lady

shediedaladyI don’t know why, but I love the name of this novel.  I’ve seen it placed high on top 10 Carr lists and was curious to see if it would live up to its reputation.  Short answer – mmm, I don’t know.  The puzzle is fascinating, yet the solution wasn’t quite fulfilling (more on that later).  The story lacks the atmosphere and urgency of other works, but is still an enjoyable read.  The reveal of the killer is uniquely done and I really liked how the novel closed out.

Published in 1943, this Merrivale tale takes place in 1940, as the threat of German air raids on England looms large.  A woman schemes to leave her older husband and escape to America with a younger man.  During a small gathering, the lovers slip out the back door and vanish – into thin air.  Their footprints are found in a dirt path leading to Lovers Leap – the edge of a 70 foot cliff, with rocks and crashing waves below.  Suicide is the original verdict, until the bodies are recovered from the sea.  Both victims were shot at close range, and yet the murder weapon is found 1/2 a mile inland.

Continue reading “She Died a Lady”

Rating John Dickson Carr – The Middle Ground

I’ve done a series of posts where I’ve looked at the reputation I’ve been able to determine for Carr’s works, dividing them into categories:

  1. The Classics
  2. Highly Recommended
  3. Recommended
  4. Commonly Criticized

Now I expose my true plan, my hidden agenda in all of this…   I have to think that many readers take their “to be read” backlog seriously.  Maybe I’m weird, but I tend to mine.  I admire the stack, fret over the order, and constantly move books around, all in the hopes of achieving the perfect list.  I don’t necessarily want to blow through only the best books all at once, so I try to spread things out – hence my lists.  To give an example, here are the top four books on my list today:

  1. The Peacock Feather Murders
  2. Death Watch
  3. Castle Skull
  4. Till Death Do Us Part

Three days ago, my top four looked like:

  1. Till Death Do Us Part
  2. Castle Skull
  3. Nine – and Death Makes Ten
  4. The Crooked Hinge

Continue reading “Rating John Dickson Carr – The Middle Ground”

Rating John Dickson Carr – Commonly Criticized

I’ve done a series of posts where I’ve looked at the reputation I’ve been able to determine for Carr’s works, dividing them into categories:

  1. The Classics
  2. Highly Recommended
  3. Recommended

Now the pendulum swings the other way, and I cover the books that are consistently criticized.  These are books that almost everyone seems to dislike.  Here they are in order of reputation:

Continue reading “Rating John Dickson Carr – Commonly Criticized”

Rating John Dickson Carr – Recommended

I’m partway through a series of posts where I categorize Carr’s books based on the reputation that I’ve found on line.  You can read my previous posts on The Classics and Highly Recommended books.

For this post, I’ll be looking at “Recommended”.  These books show up occasionally on Top 10 lists, but not nearly at the rate of my previous categories.  Here they are, listed in order of reputation.

Continue reading “Rating John Dickson Carr – Recommended”

Rating John Dickson Carr – Highly Recommended

I did a recent post where I’ve started to break down the John Dickson Carr books based on reputation that I’ve found on the internet.  To review:

I’ve created these categories based on the vibe I’ve gotten from blogs, forums, and other lists that I’ve found.  I’m obviously sensitive to avoid sources that tell me too much about the stories or could spoil the puzzles.  Here are some examples of the resources I’ve used:

For this post, I’ll be looking at “Highly Recommended”.  These are books that almost everyone seems to recommend, but they don’t cross over to the point of unanimous classics.  I don’t recall seeing anyone suggest that any of these books should be avoided.  Here they are, listed in order of reputation

Continue reading “Rating John Dickson Carr – Highly Recommended”

Rating John Dickson Carr – The Classics

Out of all of the impossible crime author’s I’ve read, John Dickson Carr has grabbed my obsession.  My entry point for most author’s has been the short story, although the mere premise of Leo Bruce’s Case for Three Detectives was enough to pull me in.  Satisfied with The Wrong Problem and Blind Man’s Hood, and tempted by reviews, I started my reading with Hag’s Nook and The Nine Wrong Answers, which seems somewhat humorous in retrospect.  Don’t get me wrong, I enjoyed both novels, but looking back, these are curious entry points.  I chose Hag’s Nook because the plot seemed interesting, and being the first Fell book, it seemed like a natural starting point.  I was intrigued by the premise of the author taunting the reader directly, which drew me into The Nine Wrong Answers.  Oh, and the fact that I found both books on eBay for like $2 helped influence my choice a bit.

Continue reading “Rating John Dickson Carr – The Classics”

The Burning Court

burningcourtBlind Man’s Hood was the second story I ever read by John Dickson Carr.  Beyond an enjoyable story, what struck me was the eerie quality introduced by the supernatural element.  The notion of supernatural should normally be a deterrent for a fan of locked room mysteries and impossible crimes.  How can you truly have fair play if anything is possible?  Carr pulled it off perfectly – providing a faithful impossible crime with a clever solution, and then introducing just enough of a supernatural element to make you rethink what you just read.

I approached The Burning Court with curiosity.  Not only does it seem to make most Top 10 Carr lists, but reviews suggested that a supernatural element was at play.  But good reviews were hard to come by – I prefer blogs that tease me enough into making me want to read a book (or avoid it), rather than put me at risk of stumbling upon some detail that ruins the puzzle.  My favorite sources provided nothing on this non-series novel.

Continue reading “The Burning Court”