Phantom Lady – William Irish (1942)

Scott Henderson is miffed that he’s been ditched by his wife on date night.  Not wanting to waste dinner reservations and tickets to a hot show, he picks up a complete stranger at the bar on a lark: they’ll enjoy a night out on the town with no expectation of making a connection or ever seeing each other again.  His companion is nice, but not especially memorable.  That proves to be a problem when Henderson returns home to find his wife murdered, the police already at the scene of the crime, and there’s some damning evidence that he’s the guilty party.

Henderson finds himself without an alibi, as he doesn’t even know the name of the woman that he was out with.  Even worse, various witnesses throughout the night – a barman, a cab driver, the wait staff at the restaurant – all testify that he was flying solo.  Sentenced to death, and with the days ticking down, Henderson spends his time behind bars while his best friend races to piece together his shattered alibi.

It’s honestly a great setup, and I hope that you forget most everything I just told you by the time that you read it, because watching the story unfold over the first 30 pages without any idea of where it’s going was a lot of fun.  That great hook though is also a bit of an Achilles’ heel.  I won’t juice up your imagination, but there are only really two practical answers to what transpired, and one of them involves a faulty narrator.  And so oddly, there I was, having absolutely lapped up the first 30 pages, yet wondering if I was willing to trek 230 more to what seemed like an inevitable solution.  Was I even going to get that much of a puzzle, other than tracking down some missing witness and learning why people claimed that she didn’t exist?  I honestly almost did put the book down to search out something in the more conventional mystery vein.  I’m so glad I didn’t, because Phantom Lady left me absolutely stunned.

I should have known that it would deliver.  JJ over at The Invisible Event has been raving about how much he’s been enjoying Cornell Woolrich’s output, and I figured I’d check it out.  Here we have the author under the pseudonym of William Irish, and while JJ hasn’t reviewed Phantom Lady, the other reviews have made Woolrich’s writing sound so promising.

And the writing is top notch.  Here’s an author who can set a mystery in New York City without beating you over the head that it’s set in New York City.  Hell, I don’t even think Woolrich mentions NYC or Manhattan.  The setting seeps through in the background though, as John Lombard – Scott Henderson’s one remaining prayer – throws a Hail Mary attempt to track down the phantom lady.  Lombard has almost nothing to go on, but with a tenacity that would make Freeman Wills Crofts’ Inspector French proud, he claws his way forward; encountering failure after failure, but somehow coming out with some minute scrap to keep hope alive.

Each potential witness pursued is almost a miniature story in its own, my favorite being a bar man who is hounded to the point of insanity. There’s a tense scene at a railway station where the hunter makes an innocent error and in the flash of an eye becomes the prey.

And then after so many hard fought victories and failures, the end comes, and wham, it was not at all in the shape I was expecting.  And what a relief, because the weak point of the story was that it didn’t seem like it would offer much in the way of surprise.  But that’s my own fault for assuming, right?

I would go on about the ending for an hour, but unfortunately it would be too easy to ruin.  There’s such a perfect book that I want to compare this to at a high level, but alas, it could lead to two way spoilers.  And so I’m left the weak proclamation that Phantom Lady is must read and it won’t let you down.

In fact I was so floored by the Phantom Lady that I immediately picked up another novel by Cornell Woolrich.  This might be my first back to back read by a single author since I binge read 37 John Dickson Carr novels (as one is bound to do…)

My edition

Tell me that the orange, blue, and white 1945 Pocket Book edition pictured above isn’t to die for.  It might seem like an odd image, but that orange thing is a hat – the one standout trait that Scott Henderson is able to remember about the phantom lady.  The cover art is a play off of the original hardback edition, but done in a slightly different style.  In a first for me, I actually consider the original art to be better, and it’s much easier to realize that the white blob is meant to be a formless face in a blue hood (embarrassing I didn’t realize that until I was nearly done with the book).

The edition is unabridged (it runs a stout 260 pages), which I unfortunately can’t claim for some of the other vintage Cornell Woolrich books that I’ve managed to find at a reasonable price.

12 thoughts on “Phantom Lady – William Irish (1942)”

  1. It sounds absolutely fantastic. I haven’t much experience of Woolrich yet (though I loved what I have) but between you and JJ I find myself wanting to very soon!


    1. I’m definitely going to be hunting down more Woolrich. As far as the vintage paperback style that I like, they’re pretty expensive, so I have a feeling that a lot of patience will be involved in building out my collection. There are some decent looking and much more readily available Ballantine editions from the early 1980s (the cover art of which look oddly similar to the Carrol and Graf editions of John Dickson Carr).


  2. I’ve skimmed this, since, as you say, I’ve not read it, but it sounds wonderful. The setup feels similar to the Woolrich novella ‘All At Once, No Alice’, so I’m curious whether one informed the other.

    Fingers crossed the American Mystery Classics team keep the Woolriches coming and we all get to enjoy this in the years ahead…


    1. Why do I keep forgetting that I’ve already read Woolrich via All at Once, No Alice? I guess it was before the big names in the genre solidified in my mind. I need to re-read it because I don’t even recall the general plot.

      I hope you manage to get your hands on a copy of Phantom Lady!


      1. I, too, hope to get my hands on this, and all Woolrich’s stuff. However, you’ll beat me to that by several decades — so I’m glad you’re off to such a great start 🙂


  3. Haven’t read the book yet, but it sounds more convoluted (in the best way) than the film. I highly recommend that you seek out that movie! It may not contain the surprises that you found in the book (just guessing, based on your review), but it’s a wonderful film noir with the rare female hero.


    1. Hmm, the movie looks like a stripped down version of the book (based on the wikipedia page). It seems like they included most of the core plot elements, but trimmed some of the plot lines. I’d love to see it.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Solving the Mystery of Murder

Investigating how classic crime writers plot their mysteries.

Long Live The Queens!

About Ellery Queen and other GAD authors

James Scott Byrnside

Author of impossible-crime murder mysteries

Countdown John's Christie Journal

A review of Agatha Christie's crime novels and short stories from beginning to end

Dead Yesterday

Classic Mysteries and Domestic Suspense


The annex to John Grant's *A Comprehensive Encyclopedia of Film Noir*

Justice for the Corpse

Reviews of classic fair-play mystery fiction - spoiler-free unless otherwise noted

Composed Almost Entirely of Books

Books read, books written, books I just spotted and covet like an ox

Mysteries Ahoy!

Detecting Great Crime Fiction

Only Detect

Book Reviews, Mostly

%d bloggers like this: