Suddenly at His Residence – Christianna Brand (1947)

SuddenlyAtHisResidenceI’ll always tout Christianna Brand as an author who can deliver an emotional blow.  Green for Danger, Fog of Doubt – even less known books like Alas for Her Who Met Me – all have a way to draw you in to the lives of a cast of characters.  Perhaps it’s her informal turn of the phrase, but the characters feel real in a familiar sense, rather than sketches on the page from 70 year ago.  The denouement comes as a punch to the gut, as real lives crumble, and a person you’ve empathized with is unmasked as the killer.

While that ability to trigger real emotion is the trait of Brand that stands out most clearly to me, she may well be among the most skilled in the field for pulling the wool over the reader’s eyes.  Her particular talent seems to be dangling a clue repeatedly in the readers face, to the point where the final solution to the puzzle comes as a natural, yet shocking realization.  John Dickson Carr certainly had this talent too, but Brand in particular excels in inflicting a sense of “damn, how didn’t I see that coming the entire time?

This is relevant to Suddenly at His Residence, as it’s known to be one of Christianna Brand’s craftiest puzzles, along with the unobtainable (except in eBook form) The Death of Jezebel.  We’re treated to not just one, but two impossible footprint crimes (a la The White Priory Murders, She Died a Lady, or The Witch of the Low Tide), in which a murder has occurred but no killer could have possibly entered/left the crime scene because of the lack of telltale tracks.

Top this off with another well known trait of the story – the impossibility isn’t solved until the final sentence of the book.  Ellery Queen’s novel The French Powder Mystery is deservedly famous for exposing a killer in thrilling fashion via its final line, but this Brand proposition was even more intriguing.  Given two hundred pages to contemplate possible solutions for a puzzle, how could it all click together in a single sentence?

Well, it does – but more on that later.

As with any good country house story, the plot revolves around a large family and a will.  Brand starts the book with a family tree and the ominous promise that two of the characters will meet their deaths at the hand of one other (a similar foreshadowing occurs in different form in both Fog of Doubt and Green for Danger).  The identity of one of the victims should be no surprise to even the most novice reader.  Sir Richard March has lost all of his children, but he has a large brood of grandchildren eyeing a piece of his pie.  Unfortunately for them, March has a tendency to throw tantrums, and his will is in a constant state of flux as a result.

A dose of sass at the dinner table results in March storming off to change his will yet again – this time cutting out all of his grandchildren and leaving everything to his second wife.  The incident coincides with a yearly ritual in which March spends the night alone in a small cottage to observe the anniversary of his first wife’s death.  The next morning he’s found dead, seemingly of natural causes, yet the will is missing.  Several other puzzling clues, such as the conspicuous lack of fingerprints on key objects, lead the police to the suspicion that murder has been committed.

Somewhat standard country house murder fare so far, but Christianna Brand swerves things into impossible crime territory with a twist.  The cottage that March died in was unapproachable on two counts.  First, it’s surrounded by thick patches of roses in full bloom – even the slightest brush would send petals fluttering to the ground.  Second, the paths leading to each entrance were freshly sanded, and yet no footprints are present at the time the body is discovered.

Brand’s not done with the impossibilities yet, delivering a second murder a few chapters later, and in unheard of fashion, again relying on an unexplainable lack of footprints at the crime scene.  A double impossible crime is rare enough in the golden age, but here we have double impossible footprints.

Of course, the joy of an impossible crime is scratching your head and trying to figure out how it could have occurred.  With a typical novel, the investigators might throw one or two false solutions your way, dispelling the conclusions just as you reach them.  Brand ups the ante significantly – by the end of the book, we’re provided at least two ways that each character in the substantial cast could have pulled off the crimes.  What starts as a pair of air-tight impossible crimes builds into a mountain of potential solutions – hardly any of which would have dawned on me.

Multiple impossible crimes and a dozen clever false solutions combine for a read that never lets off the gas.  Brand’s talent doesn’t simply lie in the strength of her puzzles.  It’s the characters that she draws you in with, creating a world in which you don’t want to see anyone tagged as the killer.  Couple that with her knack for the wry turn of phrase, and Suddenly at His Residence is pure pleasure to read.

“The big white house sprawled lazily in the sunshine, blue skies burned cloudless down upon green lawns, the air was sweet with the scent of roses and mown grass; and through the white house and across the green grass Murder stalked in the sunshine.”

Does it pay off in the end?  Oh man, does it ever.  The ending is an absolute barnstormer – without doubt one of the most exciting in the genre.  Brand swerves and double fakes, veering the story in a direction that I never saw coming.  You think of stories like The Burning Court, Green for Danger, The Ten Teacups – where the end comes as an unanticipated explosion.  This is one of those.

The famous final line twist is indeed beautiful.  You’ve had the entire book to contemplate the puzzle, over the course of which Brand has trotted out a dozen clever solutions.  One sentence rips that all to shred.  Most importantly though, it makes you think.  This is the true Brand fashion, best exhibited by Fog of Doubt.  The author doesn’t take your hand and walk you through how it all unfolded.  She lays a neat statement and then lets the reader sit there for a few minutes to think it through.

Dan at The Reader is Warned recently deemed this book one of the top 15 impossible crimes written before 1981.  I’m not ready to write my own list yet, but this is definitely a title that will be in consideration.  I give it points for two tight impossible crimes, plenty of clever false solutions, and multiple satisfying reveals.  Most importantly, it’s a brisk engaging read from front to back, never drifting towards dull.

22 thoughts on “Suddenly at His Residence – Christianna Brand (1947)”

  1. I get more and more excited at the idea of rereading Brand’s oeuvre. I had thought I would read it in order of publication, but with JJ’s upcoming expose of Fog of Doubt, plus my fervent desire for a group discussion over Green for Danger, it might unroll in a more haphazard fashion! You certainly make me want to go back to this one, especially since i have completely forgotten all aspects of the solution!


    1. What a blessing it would be to forget a solution to one of these stories! Unfortunately, I vividly recall the solutions to all books I’ve read so far. I can only hope they fade in the years to come.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. This is in fact my favorite Brand novel of all time.The puzzle is as wonderfully done as the characters and the moment when Bella delivers a blistering monologue about why she wouldn’t want the house at Swamsmere is in fact my favorite moment in all of GAD.Throughout the book,we get all these wonderful and crafty false solutions and the actual solution is even better than any of the false ones.The final line itself just puts everything into place and it definitely recalls the emotional bleakness of London Particulars last line.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. There is a great emotional bleakness, as you put it, and I think that’s what really makes these books stand out more than others. I’ll need to give this one a few weeks to sink in to figure out where this lands in Brand’s catalogue.


  3. I recall this one receiving some criticism in the past, but it’s my favorite of the Brand novels for all the reasons you mentioned. I’d rank my top 5 in order as: Suddenly at his Residence, Death of Jezebel, Green for Danger, Tour de Force, and Fog Doubt.


    1. That’s a killer top five for an author – not an ounce of fat among those titles. I think I’d rank Fog of Doubt ahead of Tour de Force though. It’s almost pointless to rank them though because they’re all so strong.


      1. Not an ounce of fat? No, I guess not, apart from the entire second half of Tour de Force, which is about as graceful as an elephant on rollerskates on ice on a boat on a big wave.

        As to Suddenly at His Residence, I really enjoyed it after not being enamoured of Green for Danger, and was pleasantly surprised at how damn good this was. She manages to walk everything along such a fine line, and while juggling the plot strands gives you characters who really live in the world she creates. I’m more of a fan of the “outside” no footprints solution than I am the “inside” one, but it’s still a damn fine novel, and a superb example of what the genre offers when it does its job well.


  4. Thanks for the review. 🙂 I read this quite a number of years ago, and I don’t recall being particularly enamoured by it – in contrast to ‘Green for Danger’ and ‘Tour de Force’. Then again, I didn’t manage to guess it’s ending, while I managed to do so for ‘Tour de Force’ and ‘Fog of Doubt’. So perhaps the puzzle was stronger than both of those novels. It wasn’t that I thought it wasn’t good, just that the story never fully gripped me. In contrast, while I guessed the ending for ‘Tour de Force’, I think I found the story more compelling?


  5. I read it too and enjoyed it very much. In fact, it’s one of my top Brand books. Up there with GREEN FOR DANGER. The title, for me, was the lure. So innocuous yet so beguiling. DEATH OF JEZEBEL, which you mentioned, was not, for me, as enjoyable because of the premise. But still an excellent puzzler. TOUR DE FORCE loses for me, on second reading. But I think I’ll take a chance, urged on by your enthusiasm, and reread SUDDENLY AT HIS RESIDENCE, only because I don’t remember much – thank goodness, in a way, for old lady memory. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Wish I had got to this post sooner so I could have joined the chat, but just to say I am SO thrilled that you enjoyed this as much as you did, and that you saw (as I am ALWAYS banging on about with Brand) that the false solution are just stacked up and incredibly good. The first solution to why there are no finger prints on the glass for example would for a lesser writer be the end of the novel, but just to chuck it out and have it taken down so quick shows a level of GAD prowess that not many got to.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Solving the Mystery of Murder

Investigating how classic crime writers plot their mysteries.

A Crime is Afoot

Reading notes from an eclectic reader of mysteries

Long Live The Queens!

About Ellery Queen and other GAD authors

James Scott Byrnside

Author of impossible-crime murder mysteries

Countdown John's Christie Journal

A review of Agatha Christie's crime novels and short stories from beginning to end

Dead Yesterday

Classic Mysteries and Domestic Suspense


The annex to John Grant's *A Comprehensive Encyclopedia of Film Noir*

Justice for the Corpse

Reviews of classic fair-play mystery fiction - spoiler-free unless otherwise noted

Composed Almost Entirely of Books

Books read, books written, books I just spotted and covet like an ox

Mysteries Ahoy!

Detecting Great Crime Fiction

Only Detect

Book Reviews, Mostly

%d bloggers like this: